Q/A Archives

November 2008

M T W T F S S
« Aug    
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930

Sign-up for RSS




Castrol

Lubricants

sponsored by Castrol

Steve Goodier

Steve Goodier
Technology Manager (Americas CVO and Global OEM)
Castrol

(800) 777-1466

Steven is an engineering graduate of Salford university (UK), and has spent his career working with engines of one type or another. After graduation, Steven spent several years working in the...more»»


Featured Question

synthetic oils
Posted by big from dt, CO, US on May 22, 2007

Are the synthetic oils any better than the regular engines oils that, and are they worth the extra money?

Synthetic oils have a lot of advantages over conventional, or mineral oils, the synthetic base stock allows the oil to be formulated more exactly than with a mineral base, this results in improved wear, deposits, oil consumption and friction characteristics.
however Synthetic oils do cost more to produce, but if you want to give your equipment the best, operate your vehicle for longer between oil changes, or work the vehicle hard then it is certainly worth spending the extra money.


Optimal Lube Oil Temperature
Posted by Charles from Carlsbad, NM, US on August 9, 2007

Mr. Goodier:

Given the increased thermal loads from emissions equipment and various other sources, what is considered to be the optimal operating temperature (range) for today’s mineral based oils? Synthetic lubricating oils? Automatic Transmission Fluids? Manual Transmission Lubes? Rear End (Hypoid) Lubes?

Thank you.

CFF

This is an interesting question, as you point out thermal loads of equipment have increased, not just because of the increase in engine outputs, but also the emissions equipemt that is being equipped is increasing thermal load.
The isue is that the ideal temperature range of fluids has not changed, so it is an ongoing battle of OEMs to ensure that their designs do not increase the temperatures further, hence the increasing number of cooling matrices on a modern vehicle.
The IDEAL temperature for a fluid is set by the temperature in which the antiwear and oxidatant additives become active, too cool and these reain dormant, too hot and they do not perform adequately, this is in the ares of 75 - 120C. The other are for consideration is the performance of the base oil itself, Synthetics and partil synthetic handel hot temperatures far better than minerals, so for temperatures above 90C for prolonged times then a synthetic makes more sense.This is an interesting question, as you point out thermal loads of equipment have increased, not just because of the increase in engine outputs, but also the emissions equipment that is being equipped is increasing thermal load.
The issue is that the ideal temperature range of fluids has not changed, so it is an ongoing battle of OEMs to ensure that their designs do not increase the temperatures further, hence the increasing number of cooling matrices on a modern vehicle.
The IDEAL temperature for a fluid is set by the temperature in which the antiwear and oxidant additives become active, too cool and these remain dormant, too hot and they do not perform adequately, this is in the area of 75 - 120C. The other are for consideration is the performance of the base oil itself, Synthetics and partial synthetic handle hot temperatures far better than minerals, so for temperatures above 90C for prolonged times then a synthetic makes more sense.


Mixing CJ4 and CI4 Plus Products
Posted by Pete from ithaca, NY, US on April 6, 2007

Is it possible to mix CJ4 with other CI4 plus products?

Although the new API CJ4 product is fully compatible with the older CI4plus specification, it is never recommended to mix oils of differing performance levels, as it could compromise the performance of the product, this is particularly important with these new products as addition of non CJ4 lubricants could affect the exhaust after treatment life of 2007 vehicles.


TBN Number and ULSD
Posted by Alex from portland, ME, US on April 6, 2007

Has the significance of a high TBN number been affected by the introduction of ULSD?

TBN is a measure to determine the engine oils ability to withstand attack from corrosive components (Acids) formed by combustion of the diesel, a higher TBN means better protection from corrosion
There are two types of acids that are formed in the combustion of an engine, sulfuric acid from the sulfur in the fuel and nitric acid from the NOX. ULSD has seen a dramatic reduction of sulfur in the fuel, which should result in reduced sulfuric acid; however EGR rates have increased dramatically which will result in higher nitric acid components. The decrease from ULSD is smaller than the increase from EGR, resulting in TBN being as important now as ever.


Supplemental Additives
Posted by Doug from little rock, AR, US on April 6, 2007

Are there any supplemental additives that can be used with the engine oil?

Supplemental additives can disturb the careful balance of specialist additives that are in a modern lubricant to control deposits, viscosity, oxidation, wear, corrosion and base oils, too much of any of these components can cause a detriment to the performance of the lubricant. The use of any supplemental additives is consequently not recommended.


1 2